By Héctor Navedo, Ed. D.

PSEL SERIES · STANDARD 4

When Students Miss the Goal, What Should the Principal Change?

Curriculum, Instruction, and Assessment

On Friday, 24 of 60 sixth graders met the criterion for explaining why two fractions are equivalent. All 60 submitted scorable work. On Monday, the principal has one team meeting to decide what to change before the next lesson: the materials, the teaching, or the assessment. Replacing the materials would cost planning time. Adding a test would cost instructional time. Keeping everything the same would leave the problem unaddressed.

The 40% tells the principal how many students met the criterion on that task. It does not tell her why the others did not. This is a hypothetical case. The decision it illustrates is real: act on the problem the evidence supports, at the smallest scale likely to address it.

What the standard means

The Professional Standards for Educational Leaders call for coherence across curriculum, instruction, and assessment. They also direct leaders to use assessment evidence within its technical limits (National Policy Board for Educational Administration, 2015, Standard 4). In practice, that means checking whether the goal, the opportunity to learn, and the task used to judge learning actually match.

Why the distinction matters

The goal was to explain equivalence, not simply to produce an equivalent fraction. A correct answer without a justification leaves the reasoning unknown. An explanation that treats two different-sized wholes as interchangeable presents a different problem. Combining both responses under “did not meet” is useful for reporting. It is too coarse for deciding what to change. The National Research Council’s assessment framework makes the distinction explicit: what students are expected to understand, what the task lets us observe, and what we infer from that observation must fit together (National Research Council, 2001).

How to apply it: make Monday’s decision

The team brings three things: the original prompt and scoring criterion, samples of student work, and the tasks students actually encountered in class. The principal asks which of three explanations has support.

  • Revise the assessment if the prompt did not clearly ask for a justification, or if the response format blocked students from showing it. Try a comparable problem with clearer directions and no mathematical hints. Keep the reasoning criterion. If students now justify their answers, the original task may have understated what they could show. A better response on a different problem does not establish why the first response was weaker.
  • Adjust instruction if students repeatedly compare fractions without accounting for the size of the whole, even when the task is clear. If the materials already offer suitable examples, keep them. Use the next lesson to contrast equal and unequal wholes and have students explain why that distinction changes the comparison. Check their reasoning on an unfamiliar problem.
  • Supplement or replace the relevant material if the review finds a concrete defect: for example, the unit repeatedly presents examples without making the unit whole clear and provides no usable tasks for reasoning about it. Replace the whole unit only if a focused repair cannot preserve the goal or address the access barrier.

Suppose the team finds that some students can explain their reasoning after the directions are clarified, while others still treat different-sized wholes as interchangeable. I would keep the materials for now if they support the goal. I would revise the prompt and teach the conceptual distinction to those who still need it. The 24 of 60 remains the original result; the new task informs the next decision. It does not erase the baseline.

What to take into the next meeting

Close the meeting with one written decision: “We will change ___ for ___ because we observed ___. ___ will lead the change. On ___, we will review ___ and reconsider if ___.” If the evidence cannot distinguish the explanations, set a date for a short recheck. Keep necessary student supports in place. Do not commit the entire school to a new program on the strength of one task.

The principal’s test is simple: Can the team explain why it chose this action over the alternatives, and what evidence would make it change course?

References

National Policy Board for Educational Administration. (2015). Professional standards for educational leaders 2015. https://www.npbea.org/wp-content/uploads/2017/06/Professional-Standards-for-Educational-Leaders_2015.pdf

National Research Council. (2001). Knowing what students know: The science and design of educational assessment. The National Academies Press. https://doi.org/10.17226/10019

Suggested citation

Navedo Aponte, H. M. (2026, November 18). When students miss the goal, what should the principal change? Leading with Vision. https://www.hectornavedoaponte.com/when-students-miss-the-goal-what-should-the-principal-change